A little while back, I had an excellent conversation brokered by the good folk at A Growing Culture. Watch and/or read below, and sign up to their Substack here.
If you’ve noticed prices ticking up every time you go to the grocery store in the last year, you’re not the only one. Food prices have risen repeatedly over the past two decades, creating hardship for households around the world. In fact, by IPES Foods’ count, this is the fourth wave of global food price crisis in just 20 years. You’ve probably heard of issues like the war in Ukraine, the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, or Super El Niño directly impacting food prices, and although they’re real risks, they tell an incomplete story.
In our latest media workshop, we wanted to interrogate the systemic underpinnings of our society that create these crises by design, so we can imagine a food system beyond the current one that keeps both producers and consumers hungry and broke.
With our collaborators at IPES-Food, Institute for Agroecology at UVM, Rooted Magazine and Agroecology Coalition, we wanted to explore questions that dig deeper, such as: why does the global food system remain so vulnerable to shocks?, who bears the cost when crises occur? and who profits from this crisis?
You can watch the full conversation or read the following conversation that has been edited for length and clarity.
Thin Lei Win, an award-winning multimedia journalist specialising in food and climate issues, and the author of Thin Ink newsletter.
Anna Jones-Crabtree, a first-generation farmer running a 15,000-acre organic farm in Montana in the United States, and a member of the Agrarian Commons and the National Family Farm Coalition.
Errol Schweitzer, IPES-Food expert and a grocery industry veteran who has spent decades on the side of how supermarkets buy, price, and sell food. And he’s also been working on New York City’s plans for public grocery stores.
Qammar Abbas, peasant rights activist who also works on his own family farm in southern Punjab in Pakistan. Kammar represents the Pakistan Peasants Coordination Committee in La Via Campesina, and is an active member of LVC’s International Youth Articulation.
Raj Patel, IPES-food panel expert, documentary filmmaker, best-selling author, and research professor at the University of Texas at Austin.
*The following conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
Thin: How are rising prices showing up in your communities?
Anna Jones-Crabtree: “Diesel fuel for our farm has gone from $2.15 last year to $6.25.”
Qammar Abbas: “Pakistan is one of the extreme examples that we have in terms of inflation and price increases. The recent data show Pakistan close to a 12% year-on-year increase in inflation. It is not only impacting consumers. It is also impacting farmers who are in debt and under IMF and World Bank austerity policies. Farmers are facing the dismantling of minimum support prices that we used to get for crops like wheat. IMF and World Bank policies are pushing countries like Pakistan to remove protections for farmers, remove fair prices, and deregulate markets. This is the most urgent time of our lives, and we need to resist and fight against this system.”
Errol Schweizer: “Our grocery bills went up about 50”% over the last ten years.
I went to the bodega the other night and bought a chocolate bar, a protein bar and some cut fruit. It cost me almost twenty dollars. In New York City, we have 1.5 million people who are food insecure. In the United States, the last count was about 48 million. We do have a crisis in the Global North as well. It primarily impacts the poorest of the poor, the working class and the working middle class.”
Raj Patel: “Here in Texas, the affordability crisis is the confluence of energy price rises, healthcare entitlement reductions and a cutting back of people’s ability to access food entitlements. About four million people use our food banks regularly. Between February and June this year, the number of referrals to food banks went up 40%.
People are suffering as a result of having to choose between spending money on food, spending money on medicine, spending money on rent, and spending money on fuel so that they can drive their cars to work.”
How much of what we’re currently seeing is really about geopolitics, and what are the deeper structural reasons that our food system is so vulnerable to these shocks?
Raj Patel: “It’s certainly the case that the war in Iran and the war in Ukraine are driving energy prices up and the price of fertiliser and wheat. But the question that doesn’t really get asked is: why does a conflict in the Strait of Hormuz matter so much for the way that we eat?
The way that we eat is hostage to fossil fuels, and there’s nothing natural about that. Two hundred years ago, a war in Iran would have made absolutely no difference to the way that food prices worked internationally. Something has happened to push us onto a system where we need so much fossil fuel. That’s the question that gets asked very rarely in the media.
The other question that doesn’t get asked is that we are hostage to the US dollar. Most countries in the Global South are indebted. When you are indebted, you have to pay back your loans in US dollars. That means you have to transform your land from feeding your domestic population into selling into an international market where you’re getting less and less for your crop.
These structural problems never feature in our discussion of geopolitics, and they should, because they feature directly in the story of why these geopolitical shocks feed through into direct hunger in the Global South.”
How much of what we pay at the till is really about higher production costs, and how much is it about pricing power of companies that control the produce reaching us? Is “greedflation” real?
Errol Schweizer: “I prefer to call it, using Isabella Weber’s term, seller’s inflation. There are legitimate crises happening, but when you have extreme market concentration at every level of the food system, those crises interact with concentrated power. You have heavily monopolised seeds and inputs. You have processors controlling 60 to 80 percent of different protein sectors. Three to four companies control the majority of sales in nearly every grocery category. Wholesale is highly consolidated. In the United States, six retailers control 60% of grocery sales.
Market concentration means pricing power.
Ultimately, this creates wealth concentration among the shareholders of these companies, and you are essentially stealing out of the pockets of consumers in order to enrich a small handful of people who have access to the market and who can use their market concentration to control prices. They leverage the crisis to justify price increases. That’s essentially the thesis of the seller’s inflation, something that I’ve independently worked on and verified for many years, and it’s something that we’re going to see continue to get worse, because we do not have the regulatory or the grassroots power yet to actually stop it.”
What does fossil fuel dependency look like on the farm? Has farming organically helped shield you from some of these shocks?
Anna Jones-Crabtree: “We’re not dependent on any synthetic fertiliser. Our farming system is dependent upon a seven-year crop rotation with integrated grazing. I think what’s challenging is that most people have a really simplistic view of our food system. Farmers grow food; consumers buy food. What’s happening is that it’s so much more complicated than that.
Frankly, we’re collectively eating oil, and synthetic fertiliser is really the Achilles heel of our agricultural system.
As a farmer, I would love to figure out how I can start putting climate change surcharges on everything that leaves the farm. If I did that, people just wouldn’t buy it. Farmers tend to be price takers, not price makers. Risk is not shared equitably between all players in the supply chain. If I get a one-pound bag of French green lentils in your grocery basket and they’re organic and selling for seven or eight dollars, I get a whopping seventy cents out of that eight dollars at the register. There is a huge discrepancy between what’s paid at the register and what’s going into farmers’ bank accounts.
Our organic system is definitely more resilient, but it’s a long-term endeavour and investment and collaboration with nature. We need to see that only 1% of the population in the U.S. is involved in production agriculture. 80% of U.S. farms have someone working an off-farm job to hold things together. The average age of the farmer is nearing 60, and less than 1% of the country’s agricultural land is inorganic, in a lower input system. So, we have some real challenges ahead and need to look at farmer livelihoods.”
What are farmers in Pakistan experiencing right now in terms of the cost of fertiliser and fuel prices?
Qammar Abbas: “Pakistan is one of the largest importers of chemical fertilisers. In 2024, fertiliser imports totalled around $618 million. Most farmers, whether they are large landholders or medium and small farmers, still rely on a production system based on fertilisers, pesticides and other external inputs.
But beyond the issue of inputs, there is another challenge that farmers in Pakistan are facing. There has been a new push for what the state and military call ‘corporate farming.’ The military and the state are inviting transnational corporations and Gulf countries to make direct investments in agriculture and the food system. There is massive land leasing and land control shifting from small farmers, tenants and peasants to these corporations. Different initiatives are being promoted under programs such as the Special Investment Facilitation Council and the Green Pakistan Initiative. They are planning large-scale land acquisitions that threaten indigenous communities, small farmers and tenants who have been cultivating this land for generations.
Countries from the Gulf region, including Qatar, the UAE and Saudi Arabia, are looking to secure food production abroad, and Pakistan’s political and economic elites are opening the door to those investments. At the same time, agricultural markets are being deregulated, minimum support prices are being dismantled, and public protections for farmers are being removed. All of this is connected to the issue of food prices.
“It’s not that farmers are getting more money while food prices are increasing. This is very important to understand. Farmers and consumers are suffering from the same policies.” —Qammar Abbas
There is a complete transformation taking place; wheat policy and other key sectors are being shifted toward market-based systems, while public institutions are being dismantled under pressure from international financial institutions.
Small farmers and peasants are resisting these changes. With the support of local communities and global farmers’ movements, we are fighting against this system. We are practising agroecology, and we are showing other farmers that it is possible to move away from corporate-dominated agriculture and begin changing the system from below.”
What policies would make the biggest difference for farmers?
Anna Jones-Crabtree: “What really needs to change is this myopic focus on commodities and crops. We’ve taken humans out of the system. We focus on subsidising specific commodities. You grow wheat and soy and corn, you win. If you grow rye and lentils and safflower and have a rotation, you lose. One thing we need to do with agricultural policy is start supporting whole farms, farmers and farmer livelihoods. Farms are so much more than production facilities. They’re not just factories that grow food. That’s why it’s agriculture, not agri-production.”
“Farms are so much more than production facilities. They’re not just factories that grow food. That’s why it’s agriculture, not agri-production.” —Anna Jones-Crabtree
Qammar Abbas: “We need guaranteed minimum prices that are set above the cost of production and reviewed regularly, backed by public purchasing from small producers. We are also demanding land redistribution and inclusive agrarian reforms; landholders and landowners from the British colonial era are still controlling most of the state actors. We want land for those who actually grow food. We want real public investment in agroecology so farmers can reduce their dependence on costly inputs, rather than being dominated by fossil-fuel fertilisers and toxic pesticides. And we need debt cancellation. We should stop making debt repayments before feeding people and giving better policies to our farmers in the countryside who are feeding most of the population.”
Errol, you’ve been involved in one of the most talked-about ideas this year, publicly owned grocery stores in New York City. Do you genuinely think that’s one way to reduce food prices?
Errol Schweizer: Yeah, I do think publicly owned grocery stores are one tool in the toolbox. We already have them in the United States. It’s called the US military commissary system. It’s a $5 billion operation that’s been publicly subsidised by the taxpayer for over 150 years. It predates the supermarket industry and outlasted Soviet communism, fully publicly funded, with 25% lower prices in the market and 8 million service members. So it’s part of our war machine.
The United States is happy to publicly fund groceries for folks who are willing to fight and die in these wars. So there’s really just a matter of making a civilian model, but it’s not the only solution. You do still need to address the market concentration, because even public sector stores will be subsumed by the monopolies further upstream in the supply chain. We could start by enforcing some of the unenforced antitrust laws, particularly around pricing. And I think we need to look at breaking up some of those larger multinational food processors. So these are the same folks who are foisting ultra-processed foods on the general public and profiting off of marketing junk food to kids. These are the big meat processors that essentially act as a cartel.
And we also need to look at expanding consumer payments. For instance, you know, SNAP (food stamps) nutrition program in the United States is one of the largest food programs in the world. It’s been rapidly rolled back by an administration that’s continuing a 45-year legacy of increasing food insecurity. So I do feel you need to also look at consumer subsidies, particularly on fresh and prepared foods. In the United States, you actually can’t use SNAP for prepared foods.
What would a less volatile food system look like?
Raj Patel: “It’s not necessarily the case that food needs to be cheaper. It’s the case that people need to be able to afford food. Here in the United States, 7 out of the 10 worst-paying jobs are in the food system. Now, you can either fix that problem by bringing food prices lower, which is also to say dropping wages. Or we could think about what it would be to raise wages and to have more purchasing power for the working class so that people do get paid better.
I think asking the question about cheapness is really important because there’s a difference between cheap and affordable. Cheap is a way of excluding environmental, labour, and social costs. Affordable is the capacity to be able to make sure that when you buy something, you are paying its full cost.
“Cheap is a way of excluding environmental, labour, and social costs. Affordable is the capacity to be able to make sure that when you buy something, you are paying its full cost.” —Raj Patel
I worry that with the moving of food into the domain of the military and of a sort of securitised state, we are moving away from democracy. What a public food system might look like would be much more government engagement in the food system through things like purchasing policy, making sure that the food we serve in schools comes from local farmers and is sustainable, and that workers are well paid in that process. The kinds of food systems I imagine are ones that are democratised, with buffer stocks and entitlements for everybody. What we need is not the military. We need the government, but in a democratic way, not in a top-down way.”
To close, what should journalists remember when writing about food prices?
Anna Jones-Crabtree: “Do whatever you can to recenter humans and farms and farmers and farming systems. Investigate the idea of risk. Where is the risk? Who holds the risk? Who’s getting paid?”
Errol Schweizer: “Grocery prices are bullshit. Every factor that goes into what you see on the shelf is completely subjective. It’s limited by our counting system. It externalises all the true costs, it minimises the efforts of labour, and ultimately, due to market concentration, funnels wealth upwards.”
Don’t take a cynical look at raising wages for food system workers as Raj talked about. And then please don’t take it for granted that grocery stores and packaged food manufacturers are good-faith actors, that aren’t also acting in the best interest of their shareholders and trying to maximise profit, particularly the largest ones. And please have sympathy for smaller operators, for independent operators, for smaller packaged food brands, for small farmers. And for food worker-led organisations that are doing their best to stay afloat in these conditions.”
Qammar Abbas: “When you write about the issue of food prices, and how the food prices are rising, ask who is setting the farm gate price. We need to see who is sitting in between the farmer and consumer, because in most of the cases in Global South countries, the farmer is also a consumer. As Raj mentioned earlier, farmers not only produce their own food, but also for foreign markets. And it is export-led and corporate-dominated agriculture.
It’s also very clear how IMF lending conditions and international trade rules are forcing governments to deregulate and align their policies and institutions with free trade agreements and go with massive privatisation, not only of agriculture, but also of health and education. In Pakistan, the Ministry of Privatisation is selling institutions to the private sector, because this is the prescription from the IMF.
Raj Patel: “Qammar is absolutely right. One of the problems with this talk of national security is that it muddies the discussion that we should be having about class. When the IMF comes in, it has its class allies in the upper echelons of business and government who are quite happy for the IMF to come in and impose certain kinds of anti-labour and anti-farmer policies. And that also helps us understand not only how this national security discourse is dangerous, but it also gives us a place to look for hope, as Errol does, for example, by foregrounding the work and ideas of workers. Because wherever you look, two out of five workers in the world are in the food system.
We just had an IPES report called Food Work that really centres the workers in the food system. And if you look at the international connections between workers, this, for me, is a source of hope. The conversations that workers are having in an Amazon warehouse in Texas are the same kinds of conversations that farm workers are having in India. There are movements and unions bringing international confluence. When you see people coming together and talking about affordability, the answers that they come up with are far more radical and far more practical than you get from the IMF.
“Food price volatility is not just about external shocks, like the pandemic, or El Niño, or the war in Iran. It is also about the choices that we have made, or our policymakers have made, on how we grow our food, who controls it, and who profits when things go wrong. Different choices are possible.” —Thin Lei Win
Offshoot is a reader-supported publication. To support our work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber.
This workshop was initially designed for journalists and storytellers, so they could go beyond the usual headlines when covering the skyrocketing prices across the world. But we think these tips that Thin shared for fellow journalists can also be useful for the rest of us in thinking about what’s behind the prices we see on the shelves:
Follow the margin, not just the price. Ask how much the farmer got, how much the retailer, processor or trader got, and how their profits changed.
Follow the fertiliser. Where does your country’s fertiliser come from, who imports it, and who profited the last time prices spiked? The world’s nine largest fertiliser companies nearly doubled their profits to $49 billion in 2022.
Follow the owners. Vanguard, BlackRock and State Street together own about 22% of shares in the world’s 100 biggest agrifood companies. Who owns the companies that set your prices?
Centre the people most affected. Nearly one in three people in the world cannot afford a healthy diet.
Go beyond the scapegoat. When an official blames a war or the weather, ask what policy choices left us exposed, and what was done after the last crisis.
Report solutions with the same rigour. Farmers like Anna and Qammar, public grocery stores, buffer stocks, school meals, local markets. Andhra Pradesh in India, for example, is transitioning six million farmers to natural farming.
If you work for the media and want to cover this story, please reach out to hyojin@agrowingculture.org. We are happy to connect you to experts and sources on the ground.
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
The New Geopolitics of Food: Navigating policies for resilient self-reliance (IPES-Food): https://ipes-food.org/report/the-new-geopolitics-of-food/
Fuel To Fork: What will it take to get fossil fuels out of our food systems? (IPES-Food) https://ipes-food.org/report/fuel-to-fork/
Another food crisis? Yes, but this time it’s different (GRAIN): https://grain.org/e/7396
On Inflation (A Growing Culture):
The Price of Passage (A Growing Culture conversation with Raj Patel):
Global hunger remains stubbornly high as another food price crisis looms (IPES-Food): https://ipes-food.org/un-hunger-report-2026-global-hunger-remains-stubbornly-high-as-another-food-price-crisis-looms/
Food, Land, and Money: The case for ending the Agribusiness Financial Complex and funding the Peoples’ Food Web (Friends of the Earth United States): https://foodlandmoney.org/
Adapt to Thrive: Transforming food systems in Africa (ActionAid): https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ki972X1st_i0FlLUsOLrHIUsvNDUfnwW/view?usp=drive_link
Peasant movements in Pakistan resist the green grab with resilience (Rooted Magazine): https://rooted-magazine.org/2025/09/05/peasant-movements-in-pakistan-resist-the-green-grab-with-resilience/
Toxic Dependency: How Agrochemicals Lock In Food System Vulnerability (Global Alliance for the Future of Food): https://futureoffood.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/toxic-dependency-how-agrochemicals-lock-in-food-system-vulnerability.pdf
Podcast explainer: Dire Straits: Hormuz, Fertilizers, and Food (podcast by TABLE, IPES-Food & Global Alliance for the Future of Food) https://fueltofork.com/episode11
Video explainer: Agroecology for More Resilient Food Systems (Agroecology Coalition):
Explainer (Agroecology Coalition): What is Agroecology?
The latest report from the DADA Alliance, Food, Land and Money, asks fundamental questions to understand the power of Big Finance in Big Ag, tracing how financial interests connect with large food and agriculture corporations, and how the pursuit of profit and shareholder returns influences what gets grown, how land is used and where money flows.
The people who feed the world deserve safe, fairly paid, and dignified work. Food Work, IPES-Food’s latest report exposes the systemic exploitation running through the global food chain and how workers are organising to win better pay, safer workplaces, and stronger labour rights.
Our article On Inflation, where we uncover the four causes of profit-driven food prices: corporate consolidation, rising input costs, agflation, and financialisation.
SAVE THE DATE! For our upcoming online rallies for peasants’ and Indigenous peoples’ right to seed. Hear from activists and leaders from the frontlines of the seed sovereignty struggle on the 2nd and 3rd of December, as part of the larger Stop UPOV campaign. Stay tuned for details!





